Blockchain in Healthcare: Overview of Applications, Challenges, and Future Directions

Sareena Wilson, Vishal Kumar Sinha, Sushma Malik^* and Anamika Rana

Maharaja Surajmal Institute, Janak Puri, New Delhi, India
E-mail: sushmalik25@gmail.com
*Corresponding Author

Received 09 July 2024; Accepted 04 October 2024

Abstract

There are numerous healthcare issues which show the potential of blockchain technology such as transparency, interoperability and security of data. Through this study, it tries to offer a very deep explanation of where the Blockchain applications today stand for in the healthcare domain emphasising on possible benefits from the technology and some known challenges that are being faced while actuating those. We then use blockchain applications in the above-mentioned aspects to explain different aspects of use of Blockchain in healthcare like supply chain management, clinical trials, secure medical data exchange and patient empowerment. We also talk about Blockchain from implementation point of view – smart contracts, consensus methods and data privacy. In this publication, we determine whether deploying Blockchain in healthcare raises ethical and legal issues and how existing issues can be addressed. In conclusion, we describe future directions for research and opportunities to use Blockchain to improve healthcare delivery and outcomes.

Keywords: Blockchain, healthcare, data security, interoperability, supply chain management, clinical trials, patient empowerment, smart contracts, regulatory compliance.

1 Introduction

Cloud sourcing employing Blockchain technology and since the potential of Blockchain technology to change security, transparency and data management was realised it has been welcomed by a plethora business. Originally concepted as the underlying technology of digital currencies like Bitcoin, it effectively expanded into a versatile solution with functionalities that go far beyond the realm of finance. In the healthcare landscape, where data security, interoperability and integrity are major challenges, blockchain cannot afford but be a revolutionary influence [1].

Blockchain technology has emerged as a disruptive force in the healthcare business, because to its decentralized and secure platform for processing sensitive health data. Blockchain is a distributed ledger technology that enables transactions to be simply and transparently recorded across a network of computer systems. In contrast to traditional centralized databases, which store data in a single location and are administered by a central authority, blockchain distributes copies of the ledger to multiple nodes, ensuring redundancy and immutability. Each transaction, or “block,” is cryptographically linked to the one before it to create a chronological chain that cannot be changed or tampered with in the past [2, 3].

Blockchain generation has good sized promise within the healthcare commercial enterprise to cope with long-status issues such as patient privacy, information protection, and interoperability. One of the primary blessings of Blockchain is its capacity to encrypt sensitive clinical records, consisting of digital health facts (EHRs). Blockchain reduces the risk of facts breaches and unauthorized get entry to through retaining health data on a decentralized ledger this is encrypted and most effective reachable with sturdy cryptographic keys. In addition to defensive affected person privateness, extra protection encourages recall amongst sufferers, healthcare specialists, and different stakeholders. Blockchain complements interoperability with the aid of ensuring easy and obvious records drift among unique healthcare systems and groups [4].

Regardless of the underlying IT architecture, facts may be standardized, confirmed, and securely shared in actual time with Blockchain. Healthcare carriers can now get admission to complete affected person facts due to the fact to interoperability, which promotes better affected person effects, stronger care coordination, and extra knowledgeable choice-making. Blockchain gives sufferers the potential to take charge of their health records and end up extra involved of their treatment process. Patients frequently have little get right of entry to to their medical statistics in traditional healthcare structures, and they’re frequently blind to how their statistics is shared and used. Blockchain-based structures, then again, empower patients with more confidentiality and autonomy with the aid of letting them efficiently maintain, control, and proportion their private medical information as they see in shape. Patients can choose which researchers, healthcare providers, or outdoor apps have get right of entry to to their data, selling a more powerful character-focused and collaborative method to healthcare transportation [5, 6].

Figure 1 Blockchain-technology-in-healthcare-industry [5].

This observe objectives to perform goals. First, a precis of Blockchain technology’s fundamental thoughts and programs inside the clinical discipline. This entails going over essential aspects of Blockchain, like immutability, decentralization, consensus methods, and clever contracts. Second, to research how Blockchain technology can be used to address a number of healthcare-associated issues, consisting of deliver chain management, affected person involvement, interoperability, and statistics security. This work attempts to spotlight the possible blessings of Blockchain adoption in healthcare and imply critical regions for further have a look at and implementation efforts via a radical analysis of the body of present day literature and case research.

2 Blockchain Applications in Healthcare

Blockchain technology holds massive ability for reworking various elements of healthcare. Here are some programs (Figure 2):

Secure Medical Data Exchange: The fragmentation of affected person records across many carriers in traditional healthcare structures poses a project to the accessibility of complete scientific information. Blockchain generation presents a secure, decentralized technique of coping with clinical information. Healthcare carriers can guarantee facts security and integrity by means of storing patient information on a Blockchain. Every transaction generates an unchangeable audit path of facts get right of entry to and changes by way of cryptographically connecting to the only before it. Patients are still in price in their fitness statistics, and they can authorize certain clinical experts to view their statistics. The chance of records breaches and undesirable get right of entry to to non-public clinical statistics is reduced via this decentralized method [7].

Supply Chain Management: The pharmaceutical deliver chain is susceptible to robbery, inefficiency, and counterfeit medicines. Blockchain era gives a transparent and impenetrable ledger for monitoring the drift of prescribed drugs and medical resources from production to shipping. In order to assure product authenticity and maintain fake items out of the supply chain, network members time-stamped and authenticated each transaction recorded on the Blockchain. By automating payment procedures and upholding agreements among events, clever contracts can lower administrative costs and increase participant agree with [8].

Clinical Trials: Clinical trials necessitate cooperation among severa stakeholders, such as sponsors, sufferers, researchers, and regulatory organizations, and consist of tricky statistics control strategies. Blockchain generation can expedite these procedures and beautify the trial information’s integrity. Researchers may additionally assure transparency and traceability at some stage in the trial lifetime by way of maintaining trial facts on a Blockchain. By automating information sharing agreements, incentive bills, and compliance tests, clever contracts can decrease administrative burdens and increase productiveness. Using Blockchain-based identity management technology, sufferers can volunteer to take part in trials and securely exchange their health facts with researchers. This improves affected person participation and makes it less complicated to discover individuals for scientific trials [9].

Patient Empowerment and Engagement: Patients are empowered by using Blockchain because it allows them to take an active role of their care and has greater manage over their fitness statistics. Using secure virtual wallets, patients can get right of entry to their Blockchain-based medical records and authorize healthcare practitioners to take a look at specific data. This lessens the need for pointless trying out and strategies and promotes continuity of care. Furthermore, while preserving privacy and anonymity, Blockchain-primarily based systems might inspire patients to volunteer their fitness facts for take a look at. Patients can participate in studies research and get hold of incentives or tokens for their statistics contributions, which encourages a extra affected person-centered and cooperative approach to healthcare innovation [10].

Figure 2 Blockchain applications in healthcare.

Patients also can use Blockchain-based solutions to maintain their privateness and secrecy even as manipulating their scientific information, taking element in studies initiatives, or maybe cashing in on their fitness data. These packages display how the Blockchain technology should revolutionize healthcare by way of improving impacted individual-centricity, transparency, and records security. The generation of blockchain generation is anticipated to have a full-size effect on the management and provision of healthcare within the future as it advances and finds further use.

3 Technical Considerations of Blockchain in the Health Sector

Blockchain technology is particularly well-ideal for applications within the healthcare enterprise because of its many technological characteristics and considerations. We explore three critical technological aspects of Blockchain software in healthcare on this phase: smart contracts, consensus procedures, and facts privateness and secrecy [11].

• Consensus Mechanisms: Consensus Procedures: These are important for making sure the safety and consistency of transactions inside a Blockchain network. In the case of healthcare, the proper consensus method have to be carried out because touchy patient records is at stake. Several not unusual consensus strategies embody Proof of Work (PoW), Proof of Stake (PoS), and Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (PBFT) [12, 13]. The choice of consensus mechanism for a given healthcare Blockchain implementation is contingent upon several aspects, including but not limited to transaction throughput, energy efficiency, security, and scalability.

• Smart Contracts: Smart contracts are self-executing contracts the usage of pc code encoding the terms. In the healthcare zone, clever contracts may be used to automate and put into effect a number techniques and agreements, such as affected person consent control, coverage claim processing, and supply chain tracking [14, 15].

• Patient Consent Management: With the use of smart contracts, patient consent may be controlled greater appropriately and independently for studies and the sharing of scientific data. The smart contract includes set up conditions that decide whether or now not get entry to to the affected person’s information is automatically allowed or prohibited, and patients are capable of publish opportunities for consent.

• Insurance Claim Processing: Smart contracts feature by using enacting predefined conditions and recommendations which can be encoded into the settlement. This permits the processing of coverage claims to be computerized. This can speed up the claims agreement method, lessen fraud, and save administrative overhead.

• Supply Chain Tracking: Using smart contracts, pharmaceutical transport networks can also song the movement of medicine from manufacturing to distributor to store, making sure authenticity, openness, and legal compliance.

A degree of automation, transparency, and reliability furnished by means of clever contracts can simplify some of healthcare transactions and procedures while lowering the possibility of fraud and error.

• Data Privacy and Confidentiality: Privacy and Confidentiality of Data: In the healthcare industry, privateness and confidentiality of information are vital since affected person statistics needs to be protected from unauthorized get entry to and exposure. The Blockchain age has made a number of solutions available to enhance information privacy and secrecy at the same time as maintaining the integrity and transparency of the information [11, 16].

$\circ$ Encryption: In the healthcare enterprise, wherein non-public affected person records wishes to be blanketed from undesirable get right of entry to and publicity, records privateness and confidentiality are important. Blockchain generation offers some of methods to enhance records secrecy and privacy while preserving information integrity and transparency.

$\circ$ Permission Blockchains: Permissioned Blockchain networks limit community participation and information get admission to to authorised agencies. This guarantees that best accredited researchers, patients, and healthcare professionals can have access to sensitive healthcare statistics.

$\circ$ Zero-Knowledge Proofs: Zero-know-how proofs permit parties to illustrate a declaration’s veracity without disclosing any extra information than simply that the declaration is authentic. By doing this, events can verify the validity and integrity of the information with out revealing any sensitive records.

4 Challenges and Barriers in Implementing Blockchain Technology in Healthcare

Blockchain generation holds top notch capability for the healthcare zone, but a number of problems and demanding situations want to be triumph over earlier than it can be carried out effectively. In this segment, we cope with 5 substantial issues and limitations, as proven in parent three [17–19]:

Scalability: There are still some of scalability issues with blockchain era, in particular in healthcare programs in which a number of statistics is generated and tested. The barriers of conventional Blockchain networks, such Ethereum and Bitcoin, in terms of transaction quantity and processing speed may additionally render them irrelevant for use in the healthcare zone. Shading, sidechains, and rancid-chain protocols are some examples of scaling solutions which can be being explored to improve the scalability of Blockchains. However, imposing those technology while retaining records protection and decentralization could be hard for healthcare organizations.

Figure 3 Challenges and barriers in implementing blockchain technology in healthcare.

Regulatory Compliance: Adherence to strict rules governing the confidentiality, protection, and privacy of impacted individuals and their records is crucial in the healthcare sector. Healthcare organizations must ensure that their Blockchain implementations comply with regulatory requirements, such as the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) in the US and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the EU. To accomplish regulatory compliance, a number of organizational, technical, and criminal requirements should be met. These consist of the need for audit records, data residency, controlled access, and encryption of documents. Implementing blockchain generation is difficult, and maintaining the legal framework for conversion compliance is fraught with difficulties, as the healthcare sector demonstrates.

Interoperability: Interoperability is the ability of several devices, software programs, and systems to exchange and realize data without any problems. Interoperability is critical in the healthcare company to enable the sharing of patient facts among various digital health report (EHR) platforms, healthcare vendors, and unique stakeholders. Interoperability will be aided through Blockchain era, which gives a standardized and safe surroundings for information transmission. But acquiring interoperability necessitates getting past technological limitations which includes semantic interoperability, protocol compatibility, and records formatting. To assure vast adoption and utilization, enterprise requirements and governance frameworks for Blockchain interoperability need to additionally be installed.

Data Standardization: The standardization of data plays a important role in making sure the consistency, overall performance, and compatibility of scientific information saved on Blockchain networks. Standardized terminology, coding methods, and data formats are essential for allowing sincere statistics alternate and interpretation among numerous healthcare systems and organizations. However, the form of information assets, formats, and crook requirements makes it tough to achieve facts uniformity within the healthcare industry. It takes cooperation across stakeholders, which includes government businesses, requirements companies, healthcare carriers, and technology providers, to expand and put into effect not unusual statistics requirements for Blockchain-based healthcare applications.

Ethical Considerations: Patient permission, records possession, transparency, fairness, and distinctive ethical worries are all relevant even as the use of Blockchain within the healthcare employer. Blockchain era creates new ethical conundrums with regard to autonomy, safety, and privacy of data. The irreversible shape of Blockchain, for example, might also provide upward push to questions concerning the protection of private clinical records and the proper to be forgotten. Furthermore, Blockchain-based definitely systems may make already-present gaps in access to property and offerings for healthcare worse. In order to deal with those moral issues, it’s far important to consist of all relevant events in open and inclusive desire-making techniques, create moral frameworks and norms for the utility of Blockchain era, and make sure that Blockchain answers placed affected person rights and welfare first.

5 Future Scope of Blockchain Technology in Healthcare

The healthcare sector might undergo full-size changes in patient care, information control, and commercial partnerships with the ability for Blockchain era. In order to get over technological barriers that have averted mainstream adoption, interdisciplinary groups are exploring interoperability standards, scalability answers, and records privateness-improving technologies (see Figure 4). This offers an abundance of options for research [2, 5, 20].

• Data Security: Blockchain offers a strong method of safeguarding scientific statistics. Sensitive fitness statistics is protected from hackers with the aid of being extremely hard for unauthorized people to access.

• Interoperability: Data sharing throughout special healthcare structures is often challenging. Blockchain can enhance the interoperability of contemporary structures, making it less complicated for physicians and hospitals to alternate affected person facts in an green and environmentally friendly manner. Interoperability: It is often difficult to share statistics throughout distinct healthcare structures.

• Patient Empowerment: The blockchain generation may additionally permit sufferers more manipulate over their very own. Patients can pick who has get admission to to and uses their non-public statistics by using being given greater authority over their care in a mental health facility.

• Supply Chain Management: Within the healthcare industry, understanding in which prescribed medications and clinical materials come from is vital. By hinting positive products along the shipping chain, Blockchain technology may also help with the discovery and prevention of counterfeit capsules.

Figure 4 Future scope of blockchain technology in healthcare.

• Clinical studies: It may be hard to manage records from medical studies. Blockchain can streamline this system even as making certain the accuracy and reliability of the facts, fostering self belief in the very last product.

• Billing and Payments: The healthcare company’s billing gadget is prone to fraud and can be complex. Blockchain generation can expedite and simplify the manner, reducing mistakes and expediting billing among physicians and coverage businesses.

• Regulatory Compliance: Healthcare institutions are required to abide through strict regulations. Blockchain must make compliance extra environmentally friendly through allowing them to overtly and certainly suggest that they’re abiding through those regulations.

6 Conclusion

Blockchain generation provides a possible method to numerous persistent troubles in healthcare, consisting of facts security, interoperability, patient empowerment, and extended transparency. Even if our know-how of the way it might advantage us has advanced, there are nevertheless obstacles to triumph over, such imposing it on a big scale, adhering to prison necessities, and dealing with moral dilemmas.

Everyone engaged inside the healthcare enterprise ought to collaborate, change thoughts, and make investments in each research and possible answers if Blockchain is to be well applied. We can use Blockchain to enhance patient care, enhance healthcare transport, and build a extra transparent, green and patient-focused healthcare gadget by way of taking part, educating human beings, and organising strict policies.

References

[1] S. Khezr, M. Moniruzzaman, A. Yassine, and R. Benlamri, “Blockchain technology in healthcare: A comprehensive review and directions for future research,” Appl. Sci., vol. 9, no. 9, p. 1736, 2019.

[2] P. Durneva, K. Cousins, and M. Chen, “The current state of research, challenges, and future research directions of Blockchain technology in patient care: Systematic review,” J. Med. Internet Res., vol. 22, no. 7, p. e18619, 2020.

[3] A. Al Mamun, S. Azam, and C. Gritti, “Blockchain-based electronic health records management: a comprehensive review and future research direction,” IEEE Access, vol. 10, pp. 5768–5789, 2022.

[4] R. Saranya and A. Murugan, “A systematic review of enabling Blockchain in healthcare system: Analysis, current status, challenges and future direction,” Mater. Today Proc., vol. 80, pp. 3010–3015, 2023.

[5] M. S. Arbabi, C. Lal, N. R. Veeraragavan, D. Marijan, J. F. Nygård, and R. Vitenberg, “A survey on Blockchain for healthcare: Challenges, benefits, and future directions,” IEEE Commun. Surv. tutorials, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 386–424, 2022.

[6] R. Paulavièius, S. Grigaitis, A. Igumenov, and E. Filatovas, “A decade of Blockchain: Review of the current status, challenges, and future directions,” Informatica, vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 729–748, 2019.

[7] J. Andrew, D. P. Isravel, K. M. Sagayam, B. Bhushan, Y. Sei, and J. Eunice, “Blockchain for healthcare systems: Architecture, security challenges, trends and future directions,” J. Netw. Comput. Appl., p. 103633, 2023.

[8] Y. Singh, M. A. Jabbar, S. Kumar Shandilya, O. Vovk, and Y. Hnatiuk, “Exploring applications of Blockchain in healthcare: road map and future directions,” Front. Public Heal., vol. 11, p. 1229386, 2023.

[9] P. Ratta, A. Kaur, S. Sharma, M. Shabaz, and G. Dhiman, “Application of Blockchain and internet of things in healthcare and medical sector: applications, challenges, and future perspectives,” J. Food Qual., vol. 2021, pp. 1–20, 2021.

[10] S. M. Abd Ali, M. N. Yusoff, and H. F. Hasan, “Redactable Blockchain: Comprehensive review, mechanisms, challenges, open issues and future research directions,” Futur. Internet, vol. 15, no. 1, p. 35, 2023.

[11] A. Odeh, I. Keshta, and Q. A. Al-Haija, “Analysis of Blockchain in the healthcare sector: application and issues,” Symmetry (Basel)., vol. 14, no. 9, p. 1760, 2022.

[12] A. Hasselgren, K. Kralevska, D. Gligoroski, S. A. Pedersen, and A. Faxvaag, “Blockchain in healthcare and health sciences – A scoping review,” Int. J. Med. Inform., vol. 134, p. 104040, 2020.

[13] S. Verma, D. Yadav, and G. Chandra, “Introduction of formal methods in Blockchain consensus mechanism and its associated protocols,” IEEE Access, vol. 10, pp. 66611–66624, 2022.

[14] A. Khatoon, “A Blockchain-based smart contract system for healthcare management,” Electronics, vol. 9, no. 1, p. 94, 2020.

[15] T. M. Hewa, Y. Hu, M. Liyanage, S. S. Kanhare, and M. Ylianttila, “Survey on Blockchain-based smart contracts: Technical aspects and future research,” IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 87643–87662, 2021.

[16] A. Saha, R. Amin, S. Kunal, S. Vollala, and S. K. Dwivedi, “Review on ‘Blockchain technology based medical healthcare system with privacy issues,”’ Secur. Priv., vol. 2, no. 5, p. e83, 2019.

[17] M. Attaran, “Blockchain technology in healthcare: Challenges and opportunities,” Int. J. Healthc. Manag., vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 70–83, 2022.

[18] F. Reegu, S. M. Daud, and S. Alam, “Interoperability challenges in healthcare Blockchain system-a systematic review,” Ann. Rom. Soc. Cell Biol., pp. 15487–15499, 2021.

[19] P. Pandey and R. Litoriya, “Implementing healthcare services on a large scale: challenges and remedies based on Blockchain technology,” Heal. Policy Technol., vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 69–78, 2020.

[20] V. Sharma, A. Gupta, N. U. Hasan, M. Shabaz, and I. Ofori, “Blockchain in secure healthcare systems: state of the art, limitations, and future directions,” Secur. Commun. Networks, vol. 2022, 2022.

Biographies

Sareena Wilson, a researcher specializing in bachelors in computer applications at Institution in Innovation in Technology and Management. My research focuses on the healthcare industry is increasingly recognizing the potential of blockchain technology to address critical challenges related to data management, security, and interoperability. This paper explores the role of blockchain in healthcare, focusing on its applications, with the aim of contributing the potential of blockchain to revolutionize healthcare data management and unlock new opportunities for innovation and collaboration is undeniable.

Vishal Kumar Sinha, a graduate with hands-on experience in Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML), was having worked on several projects during my college years. I am currently working as a developer, honing my skills in software development and technology.

Sushma Malik is working as Assistant Professor at Maharaja Surajmal Institute, Affiliated to GGSIPU, New Delhi. She has been sharing her experience and expertise in the field of academics for the past 15 years. She has a strong inclination towards both teaching and research work. Her areas of interest include Data mining, E-commerce and software engineering. She has numerous research papers published in national as well as international journals. In addition, she has also presented research papers in conferences and has attended multiple seminars. She has authored books on E-Commerce and Digital Marketing for BBA/BCOM and BCA students of GGSIPU. She also played the role of Reviewer in a number of Journals.

Anamika Rana currently serves as an Associate Professor at the Maharaja Surajmal Institute, affiliated with GGSIPU, New Delhi. With over 14 years of experience in academia, she has demonstrated a strong commitment to both teaching and research. Her academic contributions extend beyond the classroom, with numerous research papers published in esteemed national and international journals. Additionally, she actively participates in academic conferences, presenting her research findings and engaging in scholarly discourse.